While reading/listening to the 2026 Veikkausliiga season previews it struck me that a lot of the narratives heading into the season seemed to be about players who had gone through a similar development pathway, having left Finland early for Italy, and then returned. There was excitement about Ilari Kangasniemi (and maybe a little more reservedly about Axel Sandler), and Martin Kirilov, who had looked excellent in the League Cup, and there were some raised eyebrows about Kasper Paananen’s difficulties finding himself a club abroad. It doesn’t take a lot of digging to find more similar players: Gabriel Europaeus is starting his third season for Gnistan, after coming back from an underaged spell in Lecce, Arttu Lötjönen, like Kangasniemi, already returned last summer from Sampdoria, Eetu Mömmö finally managed to wriggle his way out of Lecce’s grasp in his return to SJK, having spent three prior seasons on loan, Henri Salomaa emerged at Inter after several years of Primavera for Lecce. Akseli Puukko joined KuPS from Bologna, the same place Kalle Wallius spent some time in before joining Ilves last year via IK Start in Norway.
There are even players whose spells abroad have flown under the radar a little bit, like Otto Kemppainen who spent a half year in Verona after RoPS went bust. Or Niklas Schulz, the backup goalkeeper for AC Oulu this year, who spent time at Gravina (wherever that is). And if we expand to include countries like Germany and the Netherlands, we can add Jesse Kilo who ended his 6 year association with the different HSV youth teams when signing with Ilves in the winter, Julius Tauriainen who has been back from Freiburg already for some years, Saku Heiskanen who it feels has had a whole career in between leaving from Hoffenheim and breaking out at Gnistan, and Iiro Mendolin who returned from Groningen last summer. Emmanuel Patut has been back from Wolfsburg for such a long time that it almost feels unfair to include him, likewise Saku Ylätupa who has been trying to find his feet for what feels like forever after his move to Ajax, and has now landed at Gnistan. Some have had a more meandering path back (like Tauriainen who spent some time in Poland, or Mömmö who was on loan in Iceland, or Ylätupa), but they’ve all gone early, and decided to come back in some form.
It’s been something of a bubbling conversation for a longer time. I remember having discussions about whether Martti Haukioja’s move to Italy was a good idea at the time, which would have been around 2017/2018. But I think it rose to the fore a couple of years ago, when the promising Finnish U17 age group saw a handful of players moving to Italy at the same time – Kangasniemi, Sandler and Kirilov among them. There was even a piece written about it by MTV3 at the time. It’s a piece of journalism that I remember putting in my back pocket at the time, thinking that it would be a fun exercise to see how well it holds up after percolating for a couple of years. Well, now it’s been a couple of years, and I think the map graphic in that piece is a pretty good place to start:

Of the players on the map, 6/13 have moved back to Finland within the last year or so, of the others, I know that Weiss, Terrnava and Daldum were flirting with returning last year, and might still do so this year. Daniel Armstrong has played his first adult minutes this season, aged 21, at Serie C-level (roughly between Veikkausliiga and Ykkösliiga in terms of quality). Dren Terrnava similarly, although he is a year younger – both players have appeared for fewer than 100 minutes. Samooja and Happonen are goalkeepers, so it’s difficult to gauge what their current levels are and how far away they are from first team football. It could be equally reasonable to expect them to return to Finland soon – following in the footsteps of Hugo Keto as an example – as it could be to see them go the way of Viljami Sinisalo or Lucas Bergström, who have managed to leverage their leaving Finland early into playing time at the highest level.
This leaves Niklas Pyyhtiä, who is an exception among these players, because he didn’t sign on a Primavera contract when he joined Bologna. This means that the club has had more of an incentive to prioritize his playing time, as he has been on higher wages, and had a higher transfer fee attached to his signing. He is on his third season of Serie B football, a somewhat higher level than Veikkausliiga, without having really established himself as a starter. He also made his debut for the Finnish national team this year, and even managed to score on his debut.
Out of these 13 players, I would say that none have had a successful go of their Italian adventure. I could see an argument for Pyyhtiä, but he is still quite far off making it for Bologna, and has mostly been riding the bench in Serie B for the past two years. Next season will be his age 24 season, and his contract is up in the summer. At this point, I think his career trajectory is closer to Mehmet Hetemaj (several seasons as a starter in Serie B, a handful of Finland caps) than Perparim Hetemaj (hundreds of matches in Serie A, tens of Finland caps) – which is probably a median outcome for him, although it still feels a bit underwhelming.
Finnish football is going through something of an existential crisis, and has been for a long time. The lack of playing time for young players is an issue that has been gaining some traction in the media recently, but I don’t think that has had any tangible impact on how squads are constructed or how young players are viewed. There have been some green shoots: KuPS’ sales of Siltanen, Ruoppi and Toure; the transfer fee increases from Skyttä to Liimatta to Ruoppi would suggest a market that is growing; Inter seem to have the most consistency between ideas and implementation for squad building that I can remember.
But at the same time, KuPS’ reaction to selling Ruoppi and Toure was to sign Gasc and Moreno, playing time for young players is down across the board. What should have been an inspirational example for other clubs looks to have been forgotten about as soon as the new season started.
Earlier this year, Jussi Leppälahti made some pointed comments about the state of young Finnish players. Whether you think he’s right in his opinion or not*, it is an opinion that is shared by many coaches in the league: there aren’t enough good young players. I think it’s less a matter of quality than it is a matter of volume (although in reality it is probably a bit of both) – a country like Finland just can’t sustain a constant stream of young players to countries like Italy or Germany while providing enough material for domestic teams to build around.
Yes, the domestic teams also carry a large responsibility in providing a realistic plan and pathway for these players. It is understandable if, say, an Ykkösliiga/Ykkönen/Kakkonen team decides to cash in on an underaged transfer abroad, because, realistically, it’s the most they are going to be able to earn from their work in developing the player (and in Ykkönen/Kakkonen, the first team exposure isn’t worth as much for the player), but that excuse just isn’t applicable for the larger teams. This is something where basically every organization in Finland falls short.
That being said, a lot of the times, these early transfers happen despite the club rather than because of. They happen because players’ parents fear that the domestic training environment isn’t competitive enough, they happen because the players’ representatives push for that type of deal – some representatives more than others – they happen because of poor communication between club and player, and because of a lack of information about what life in Primavera (or the other-country equivalent) is like. They also happen, frankly, because the stated position of Palloliitto, is that this is the best way to develop as a player.
When thinking about this topic, I always try to put myself in the shoes of one of these players. Imagine being 16 or 17, having always been the most talented player in your environment, whether it’s your team or your school or just playing with your friends. Your dream has always been to become a professional footballer. When sketching out your career arc, you’ve always imagined going to one of the big teams in one of the big leagues. In your dreams, the natural development path for you has always included a photo opportunity with your name on a big team’s shirt. When that chance actually comes along, it’s like a manifestation of everything you’ve ever wanted – it would require superhuman amounts of level-headedness to think about it objectively. Imagine if your parents, your agent, your club, your Football Association are also pushing you in the same direction, how can you reasonably be expected to make an informed decision?
This is a topic that I’ve been investigating from different angles for a long time, in fact, I think it’s one of the most central questions for Finnish football: should players leave Finland as early as possible? I’ve written about it before, I feel like I’ve made my opinion on it clear, but I’ve never figured out the right way to properly analyze it. Whenever I’d think about it, I’d stumble upon an example for which it doesn’t apply – what about Luka Hyryläinen, going abroad early seemed to have worked out for him? Or Oliver Antman, Leo Walta, Fredrik Jensen, Juho Talvitie?
So what I did was I went through all the players who have played for any Finnish national team group, youth or senior, since 2010, and I checked a couple of things:
- Did they go abroad?
- Did they make a proper debut in their domestic team before leaving?
- Did they go abroad to play youth football?
But also:
- Did they come back to Finland before breaking out abroad?
- At what age did they come back?
- How many minutes (of Veikkausliiga or Ykkösliiga) did they play in the season they came back?
- How many minutes did they play the season after they came back?
As well as:
- Did they peak in a top 5 league?
- Top 10?
- Top 25?
- Veikkausliiga or lower equivalent?
- And have they already reached their hypothetical peak?
What I found was interesting, and I’ll go through the results in more detail below, but the thing that I realized was that when thinking about this, I was suffering from selection bias. I was only remembering the positive exceptions, because they are memorable. I was forgetting about the negative exceptions because they so quickly disappear from the radar. Or do you remember players like Onnipekka Pajula, now 22 and without a club, who went to Groningen in 2020? Abukar Mohamed who went to Lazio and retired before coming back to Finland, and is now playing in the fifth tier? Tobias Fagerström, Juho Ojanen, Akseli Kalermo, Tuure Mäntynen, Topias Järvelä, Ville Räty? Even Lucas Kyllönen, who had some promising appearances for SJK Akatemia in 2024, is now 19 and without a club, after spending time in Genoa Primavera.
Which isn’t to say that going abroad early is something that never works out but that it’s difficult to make an informed decision about it because you tend to forget the players for whom it doesn’t work.
As a start, some words on the data collection. There is a lot of subjectivity inherent in this analysis, for example, regarding a player’s peak (whether they’ve reached it or not), regarding a player’s breakout (how much do they need to play to be considered broken out), and regarding a player’s level (what is the cut-off for top 5, top 10, top 25) so bear this in mind. My thinking has been that a player’s level is a combination of the level he’s playing at, plus the level of the performances at that level. So for example, Benjamin Källman has never played in what I would consider to be a Top 10 league (there is obviously an argument that 2. Bundesliga would fit that level, but again, it’s subjective), but he’s played well enough in Ekstraklasa and 2. Bundesliga, that you could argue that he’s played at a Top 10 league level anyway. The league level is also less some objective measure of quality, but rather a heuristic – they should also be considered category names rather than indicators of the actual amount of leagues within the category. I consider a breakout to be the player playing a significant amount of minutes (1000 or so) in one season at the level, and I’ve brutally just estimated whether I think the player can still reach another level or not when considering their peak.
The research suggests that the players in this sample who left Finland (a total of 202 players) for youth football (60 players) had a diminished probability of peaking at a higher level than Veikkausliiga (players who I consider to have already peaked) compared to leaving for first team football (142 players). 12% of players who left for youth football peaked at at Top 10 league level or higher, compared to 23% for players who left for first team football. The same effect can be seen for players who peaked at a Top 25 league level (13%/25%). What follows, then, is that 75% of players who left for youth football peaked at Veikkausliiga level (or lower), compared to 51% who left for first team football.

These findings, firstly, indicate just how difficult it is to break out in international football, even leaving for first team football from the Veikkausliiga is no guarantee for ever breaking out at a higher level, but it also shows, that there’s a clear benefit to continuing to develop in Finland, rather than leaving abroad early. If we adjust to include only players who went abroad, then came back to Finland before breaking out in their first stint abroad, we find that there are only two players who have managed to go abroad, come back, go abroad again, and peak at a Top 10 level or higher (Teemu Pukki and Benjamin Källman – Källman is also an edge case, because he never truly left the first time around, instead went on a series of loans), so being selective about when to move seems to be the right play.
If we have a closer look at the players who went abroad, then came back, we can also look at how the time spent abroad affected their playing time upon return. This, again, is a bit subjective, because there are cases where a player hasn’t returned to a Veikkausliiga team, so the decision was to count Veikkausliiga and Ykkösliiga minutes the same, make a level adjustment, or disregard anything below Veikkausliiga. I decided to opt for just considering VL and YL the same, even if they aren’t quite comparable. I also only consider the playing time on their return season + 1, to adjust for players arriving mid-season. So Kasper Paananen returned in his age 20 season, when he played 1328 minutes in Ykkösliiga, but we do the comparison on his age 21 season when he played 1076 minutes in Veikkausliiga, roughly 7% more than the age 21 average in Veikkausliiga.

The data suggests that a player returning to Finland after a stint abroad receives less minutes upon their return than an average same age player. The difference is not significant between the two categories, with players who left for youth football receiving 11% minutes less than average, and players who left for first team football receiving 13% less. If we split the data by ageseason returned, we can see that the effect is larger for under 20 year-olds, suggesting that leaving early, then coming back, is a less optimal path than staying in the league and fighting for a spot in the team.
We return, then, to the players at the start – Ilari Kangasniemi, Axel Sandler, Kasper Paananen, and wonder whether this information would have affected their decision making at the time of leaving Finland. My gut feeling is no. These are just numbers in a spreadsheet, and if you’re an elite level talent (even at Finnish scale), my guess is you look at these numbers and imagine that you’re built different, because you’ve yet to see any indication of the opposite. I even imagine that most of the players who went abroad for youth football, and came back worse for wear, would struggle to realize that this is what has happened, because it’s impossible to know what an alternate path would have led to, and the experience will have been significant on the personal side. So I don’t think information is enough. There also needs to be some sense of authority behind it. Whether it’s Palloliitto, the league, the teams, the agents – someone has to forcefully want the players to stay in order for it to happen. I think that this is one of the foundations that a better league needs to be built on – a shared view, among all parties, that keeping our best young players around is universally beneficial.
This research is a work in progress, since so many players have moved abroad in recent years, we will have a much better understanding of the situation in 5-10 year’s time, but these are nevertheless numbers to anchor a conversation around. If a person of authority in Finnish football indicates that they think a player should go abroad for youth football, as happens quite frequently, I would especially challenge journalists in Finland to ask what they base their feeling on, and whether they’ve done any research to back it up, because the future of Finnish football is dependent on getting this thing right. For parents of talented players, frustrated with the development environment in Finland, I would encourage you to reach out to players who have gone abroad for youth football, to ask them about the realities of playing in a foreign academy – language barriers, social isolation, predatory contracts – and to reach out to more experienced players who can reflect back on the decisions they’ve made in their careers, and whether they have any pointers. If you need help getting in touch with players, I can help with that: get in touch via BlueSky or minorleaguesoccer@gmail.com
*I can see where he’s coming from, but my larger issue is that I think the perspective is wrong. A 16-year old shouldn’t be good enough to be able to play a starting role in a national league, but one of the main purposes of a national league – according to me – is to provide opportunities to domestic young players anyway, especially if they have individual attributes that are of a sufficient level. It boils down to the difference between ability and potential – I can buy the argument that we don’t have enough young players with the ability to contribute immediately, but it’s categoryically wrong to state that we don’t have young players who have the potential to do so.













































